D&C GLug - Home Page

[ Date Index ] [ Thread Index ] [ <= Previous by date / thread ] [ Next by date / thread => ]

Re: [LUG] unifi and soho wifi controllers

 

On 29/10/2018 19:24, stinga wrote:

> Which Ubiquity hardware are you looking at? I know that some features 
> are not enabled on my controller but then I would not use them anyway.

APs only - I really, really don't want to be manoeuvred into having to 
use any of their switching or routing gear by them tactically 
withholding features unless you're using their stack. The Ubiquiti SDN 
controller will live in a docker container on an internal system to 
manage them although I'm not necessarily _completely_ opposed to the 
little Cloud key device controller if absolutely necessary. As long as 
it can be utterly segregated from the internet while retaining full 
internal functionality. For that reason I'm not touching the USGs under 
any circumstances.

I'm looking at the full range of APs - I'm expecting to end up with a 
mix of 3-5 them initially. It's not like I live on a farm or anything, 
it's just a normal detached 2 up 2 down with a 60' back garden but I am 
intending to do this properly and once only. It's well insulated and 
wifi inside the house does suffer which is why I've run 10Gb ethernet to 
every single room and the bottom of the garden (shed+summerhouse - need 
internet there too!). Initially an upstairs AC Pro, a conservatory AC 
Lite and another AC Lite at the end of the garden should be fine but I'm 
thinking of the future and the staggering amount of bandwidth we use 
even now. Even if I've got 2x10Gb ethernet drops in every room and 
pervasive 2.4GHz wifi everywhere that's not going to cut it for long. I 
see a very near-future scenario where I put a 5GHz 802.11ac capable AP 
in literally every single room.

This is basically a once in a lifetime chance approved by the 
purse-holder ("fix the damn wifi for god's sake!") that's taken months 
to even get this far: rewired most of the house, redecorated half of it 
after smashing holes in everything for cable drops, upgraded 
distribution board, the lot. There's a proper rack in the garage with 
the patch panel now waiting to be stuffed with expensive new gear and of 
all things I've ended up stalled on the lack of decent/objective/honest 
featureset comparisons of the major SOHO wifi resellers.

To turn the question around, what Ubiquity gear do you have/experience 
with? Are you on the SDN controller and if so, which version/type? What 
features don't work?

Ta
-- 
The Mailing List for the Devon & Cornwall LUG
https://mailman.dclug.org.uk/listinfo/list
FAQ: http://www.dcglug.org.uk/listfaq