[ Date Index ] [ Thread Index ] [ <= Previous by date / thread ] [ Next by date / thread => ]
So I'm finally doing some serious home network upgrading but it's been a three or four years since I did any serious wifi stuff and that was mostly enterprise level: Cisco and rackmount AP controllers, MPLS, site-wide installs, meshed controllers mounted outside on masts, that kind of thing. Overkill for a normal sized property even by my standards so I've been brushing up on all the new (well to me at least) shiny SOHO stuff like Ubiqiti and Microtik. Anyone got any recent experience, particularly Ubiqiti? I'm most interested in the controller/management setups as they seem to have rocketed forward in sophistication compared to the horrid stuff I was using which mostly involved serial cables or if I was really lucky, a flaky http interface. By contrast the Ubiqiti Unifi ecosystem looks amazing - slick management interfaces with monitoring and configurations options that actually work! Predictably it's the cloud stuff I'm wary of even though I can understand why a cloud-based SDN controller could be a really nice thing for many people who are less control-freaky. Remote access just for a start, single sign on, apps on your phone, checking home automation and CCTV stuff etc all sound lovely to be fair and I would actually like all of those things... but under my terms. All the other infrastructure is already in place anyway - router, firewall, VPN, VLANs and so on so I don't need the new gear to do any of that (although I am actually open to upgrading pretty much everything whilst I'm at it and I definitely need a new core switch). What I'm trying to ask I think is how well does this fancy new SOHO wifi gear drop in to an existing highly organized network? Does the standalone SDN controller have all the features that the "cloud key" hardware controller, a rackmount controller or the remote cloud controller have? Ideally I want to run the SDN controller on an internal docker container which will live on a segregated VLAN provisioned from the switch and remote access, routing, access control and so on will be handled elsewhere. The potential deal breaker for me I guess is that Ubiqiti seem a bit like the Apple of wifi and seem a bit like they really, really want you to whole-heartedly buy into the whole stack/ecosystem: I don't _need_ any of their vertical integration or cloudy crap but I do _want_ their slick looking wifi management. But then I'm also looking at Microtik who seem like the anti-Ubiqiti. Any thoughts? I'm not trying to do an end run around hard work here and I've obviously got a lot of reading to catch up on :] Advice or suggestions would be appreciated. Cheers -- The Mailing List for the Devon & Cornwall LUG https://mailman.dclug.org.uk/listinfo/list FAQ: http://www.dcglug.org.uk/listfaq