D&C GLug - Home Page

[ Date Index ] [ Thread Index ] [ <= Previous by date / thread ] [ Next by date / thread => ]

Re: [LUG] Ethernet Router- recommendations?

 

I haven't had too many problems with my WRT54Gs (plural, I have two) but 
then they don't route, they are only used as access points. Either way 
the wireless is rock solid and I'd buy another to use as an access point 
if I needed to (I'm also not running the stock linksys firmware, I'm 
running DD-WRT).

My Cisco ADSL router has also been excellent since I got it, but I'd 
expect it to.

David Brook wrote:
> I have obviously been extremely unlucky with my Linksys experience.
>
> I am about to take yet another back to PC world.
>
> My first, a WAG54g just died (almost as the guarantee ran out - I say almost 
> as - I should have said 'just after') - but had been plauged with spurious 
> dropping of connections, locking out etc.  I was using it purely as a 
> gateway, NAT translator and firewall.
>
> My second, a WAG54GS lasted about 3 weeks - also used in the same way, also 
> spuriously dropping connections and locking up until one day it just would 
> not switch back on.
>
> The third (a replacement WAG54GS) is currently in use but still causing me 
> grief and about to go back.. Although on the latest firmware it still drops 
> the connection, locks up etc.  It needs regular rebooting to reconnect.  The 
> lights do not show the correct status.  Switching the B. thing on can take 5 
> mins of intermittent pressing the stupid software based on/off switch before 
> the grade A? hardware will realise someone is trying to interract with it.
>
> My sister has the next model up, cannot recall the model, looks the sme but 
> with two aerials.  She is experiencing the same problems.
>
> The wireless capability on ALL of them has been C..P to say the least.
>
>
> Maybe fifth time lucky, or then again maybe I shall dump Linksys as 
> suggested by numerous others and try something else this time.
>
> I thought Cisco backed Linksys would be a good bet - but no longer think so.
>
> I would definitely NOT recommend linksys, but would also be keen to hear of 
> other router/broadband gateway options - for me, wireless is not an issue as 
> I have Cat 5e wired the entire house based on my Linksys wireless 
> experience.
>
> Cheers
>
> David
>
>
>   


-- 
The Mailing List for the Devon & Cornwall LUG
http://mailman.dclug.org.uk/listinfo/list
FAQ: http://www.dcglug.org.uk/linux_adm/list-faq.html