D&C Lug - Home Page
Devon & Cornwall Linux Users' Group

[ Date Index ][ Thread Index ]
[ <= Previous by date / thread ] [ Next by date / thread => ]

Re: [LUG] OT: New CD Formats?



On Wednesday 07 January 2004 16:37, Gemma Peter wrote:
About a year ago odd things started happening on my stereo, for some
reason some of the newer music CDs wouldn't work, the stereo couldn't
detect the tracks, however they played OK in a different CD player and
on my laptop.

This would occur consistantly for a CD even if it was brand new (no
scratches or dirt). Sometimes one disk out of a two disk set would play
and the other wouldn't!

I tried burning a copy of an affected disk to see if it was a fault with
the actual CD (CD-Rs normally play fine in the stereo). The copy has the
same effect on the stereo as the original.

My stereo is quite old, have their been recent changes in CD formats
that might account for this effect? Copy protection perhaps? Though I
don't see why a company would go to the trouble to copy protect one disk
of a set and not the other(s). Has anyone else encountered this?

A few thoughts

Check that the lens is clean on your stereo cd player and not clogged with 
dust. An old Denon player of mine was very difficult to clean due to a lip 
around the lens.

It could be something to do with copy protection but in theory this should 
not be affecting an old audio cd player.  Copy protection systems vary but 
most seem to incude the idea of creating a multisession cd with the final 
session left open or pointing erroniously past the end of the disk.  This 
is intended to fool multisession aware players - whether it does or not 
depends largely on the hardware - but simple audio cd stereos should be 
unaffected as they just read the information from the first session.  Take 
a close look at the cd covers.  Information about copy protection is often 
included in very tiny print.

Rather than copying an image of the cd, it might be a good idea to make 
sure you have a clean copy of the music data, for example by ripping the 
data into wav files with cdparanoia -B then using your favourite burning 
utility to write the files to a new cd in a single closed session.

Tony
-- 
404 Future not Found

--
The Mailing List for the Devon & Cornwall LUG
Mail majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxx with "unsubscribe list" in the
message body to unsubscribe.


Lynx friendly